--- title: The “Cheapest” Worker Safety Solutions Can Be the Most Expensive description: While fiscal responsibility is important, the inexpensive “solution” can end up being the least effective when it comes to ensuring worker safety—and may cost more in the long run. Learn about how an upfront investment in workplace safety can improve your long-term bottomline. image: https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/cheap-expensive.jpg --- [![carbis solutions logo](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/logo-new.png)](http://www.carbissolutions.com/) - Call UsUS 1-800-948-7750 Global +1-843-669-6668 - [Careers](https://www.paycomonline.net/v4/ats/web.php/jobs?clientkey=49074D9C17442AAF1998B33263B06D96) - Products![](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/drop-down-clear-4.png) - [Complete Truck and Rail Loading Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/complete-truck-and-rail-loading-systems/) - [Loading Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/loading-platforms/) - [Elevated Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/elevated-platforms/) - [Elevated Truck Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/elevated-truck-platforms/) - [ISO Container Safety Platform](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-safety-platform/) - [Truck Loading Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/truck-loading-platforms/) - [Single Hatch Truck Loading & Fall Protection Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/single-hatch-truck-loading-and-fall-protection-systems/) - [Multi Hatch Truck Loading & Fall Protection Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/multi-hatch-truck-loading-and-fall-protection-systems/) - [ISO Container Loading Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-loading-platforms/) - [Portable Truck and Rail Access Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/portable-truck-and-rail-access-systems/) - [Railcar Loading Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/railcar-loading-platforms/) - [Single Car Train Access & Loading Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/single-car-train-access-and-loading-systems/) - [Railcar Multiple Hatch System](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-multiple-hatch-system/) - [Unit Train Loading Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/unit-train-single-hatch-system/) - [Railcar Hopper Car Handrail](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-hopper-car-handrail/) - [Transloading and Portable Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/transloading-and-portable-systems/) - [Platform Catwalks](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/platform-catwalks/) - [Pipe Racks](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/pipe-racks/) - [Accessories](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/accessories/) - [Operator Sheds](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/operator-sheds/) - [Swing Gates](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/swing-gates/) - [Limit Position Switches](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/limit-position-switches/) - [Warning Lights](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/warning-lights/) - [Drive Off Protection](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/drive-off-protection/) - [Enclosures](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/enclosures/) - [Railcar Enclosures](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-enclosures/) - [ISO Container Enclosures](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-enclosures/) - [Unit Train Enclosures](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/unit-train-enclosures/) - [Truck Enclosures](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-enclosures/) - [Gangways & Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/gangways-safety-cages/) - [Wide Gangways](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/wide-gangways/) - [Flat Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/flat-ramps/) - [Railcar Flat Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-flat-ramps/) - [ISO Container Flat Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-flat-ramps/) - [Truck Flat Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-flat-ramps/) - [Unit Train Flat Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/unit-train-flat-ramps/) - [Telescoping Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/telescoping-ramps/) - [Railcar Telescoping Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-telescoping-ramps/) - [Unit Train Telescoping Ramps](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/unit-train-telescoping-ramps/) - [Folding Stairs](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/folding-stairs/) - [ISO Container Folding Stairs](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-folding-stairs/) - [Truck Folding Stairs](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-folding-stairs/) - [ISO Container Tread](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/iso-container-tread/) - [Track Mounted Gangways](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/track-mounted-gangways/) - [Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/safety-cages/) - [Railcar Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-safety-cages/) - [Unit Train Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/unit-train-safety-cages/) - [Truck Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-safety-cages/) - [Custom Safety Cages](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/custom-safety-cages/) - [Loading Arms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/loading-arms/) - [Fluid Loading](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/fluid-loading/) - [Top Loading Arms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/top-loading-arms/) - [Bottom Loading Arms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-bottom-loading/) - [Dry Goods Loading](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/dry-goods-loading/) - [Railcar Dry Goods Loading](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-dry-goods-loading/) - [Loading Arms Accessories](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/loading-arms-accessories/) - [Cam and Groove](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/cam-and-groove/) - [Hose Handlers](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/hose-handlers/) - [Swivel Joints](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/swivel-joints/) - [Dry Disconnects](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/dry-disconnects/) - [API Couplers](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/api-couplers/) - [Spill Containment](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/spill-containment/) - [Grounding Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/grounding-systems/) - [Railcar Grounding System](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/railcar-grounding-system/) - [Truck Grounding System](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/truck-grounding-system/) - [Canopy Systems](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/canopy-systems/) - [Flatbed Fall Protection](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/flatbed-fall-protection/) - [Flatbed Operations Overhead Tarping](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/flatbed-operations-overhead-tarping/) - [Flatbed Operations Tarping Platforms](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/flatbed-operations-tarping-platforms/) - [Marine Gangways and Ladders](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/marine-gangways-and-towers/) - [Ship and Barge Access Gangways](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/ship-and-barge-access-gangways/) - [Marine Stage Gangways](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/marine-stage-gangways/) - [Marine Ladders](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product/marine-ladders/) - Services![](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/drop-down-clear-4.png) - [Loading Rack Safety Assessments](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/loading-rack-safety-assessments/) - [Scheduled Maintenance](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/scheduled-maintenance/) - [Training](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/training/) - [What’s the Solution](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/consulting/) - [Our Process](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/our-process/) - [Solutions](https://content.carbissolutions.com)![](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/drop-down-clear-4.png) - [Liquid Trucks](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/liquid-trucks/) - [Hopper Trucks](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/hopper-trucks/) - [ISO Container Fall Protection](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/iso-container-fall-protection/) - [Flatbed Trucks](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/flatbed-trucks/) - [Liquid Tank Cars](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/liquid-tank-cars/) - [Unit Train Fall Protection](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/unit-train-fall-protection/) - [Pneumatic Hopper Car Fall Protection](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/dry-hopper-cars/) - [Loading Arms And Hose Handlers](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/fluid-handling/) - [Marine](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solution/marine/) - [Workplace Safety Solutions](https://www.carbissolutions.com/workplace-safety-solutions/) - [Loading Rack Safety Solutions](https://www.carbissolutions.com/loading-rack-safety-solutions/) - [Resources](https://content.carbissolutions.com)![](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hubfs/drop-down-clear-4.png) - [Case Studies](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/case-studies/) - Blog - [The Workplace Safety Blog](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog)< - [Carbon Solutions News](https://content.carbissolutions.com/newsblog) - [Whitepapers And Guides](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/whitepapers-and-guides/) - [Videos](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/videos/) - [Events](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/events/) - [Product Documentation](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/product-documentation/) - [About Us](http://www.carbissolutions.com/safety-equipment-projects) - [Contact An Expert](https://www.carbissolutions.com/contact/) Menu Home Products Services Solutions Resources Resources Resources The Workplace Safety Blog ## Safety & Fall Prevention Insights From Carbis Solutions # The “Cheapest” Worker Safety Solutions Can Be the Most Expensive The Carbis Team | safety | Oct 2, 2018 12:35:53 PM Managers worth their salt are always looking out for their company’s best interests, seeking the best solutions to operational challenges to keep products flowing and workers safe. While fiscal responsibility is important, the least expensive “solution” may end up being the least effective when it comes to ensuring worker safety—and can end up costing more in the long run. A petrochemical company recently asked Carbis Solutions to provide a quote for an equipment upgrade on a loading rack. The upgrade was needed to accommodate additional product handling and switching from tank trucks to ISO containers. ![cheap-expensive](https://content.carbissolutions.com/hs-fs/hubfs/cheap-expensive.jpg?width=300&name=cheap-expensive.jpg)After submitting a proposal, we visited the company to talk about the parameters of the project and what else we could do to assist them. When we arrived, we encountered a challenge from the project manager, who questioned why we felt confident enough about obtaining their business to be onsite already. He indicated that our proposal was $10,000 higher than a competitive bid he had received from another company. His basic question was, “Why in the world would I want to spend more with you to buy similar equipment?” **Comparing Apples to Oranges** We explained that while the equipment appeared similar in nature, it was in fact quite different. After in-depth discussions with key stakeholders at the facility, we had discovered that the standard equipment we had been asked to quote on would require relocating existing piping. By safely modifying the equipment we were asked to provide, we could accommodate their needs without having to relocate the piping, accounting for the $10,000 cost differential. The project manager verified this information and realized that not having to relocate the piping provided several major advantages, including $30,000 in cost savings; less down time as the loading rack would not be out-of-service as long; and more time for managers to focus on other key projects. Not only did the company select Carbis to provide its safety equipment, the project manager indicated we would be their primary supplier moving forward. He was also kind enough to call his counterpart at one of the company’s largest facilities in the country to recommend they sit down and talk safety with us. **The Carbis Way** Had the company gone with the “cheapest” option, it would have been far costlier for them in the long run, in both time and money.[Optimizing the solution is the Carbis way.](https://www.carbissolutions.com/workplace-safety-solutions/) We always look beneath the surface and talk to our customers, to fully understand what they need so that [we can deliver the most beneficial, cost effective solution possible.](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/consulting/)   [![New Call-to-action](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/455611/f50a8add-3868-40b4-9f9b-c1442d14048b.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/455611/f50a8add-3868-40b4-9f9b-c1442d14048b) [View All Posts](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/) [Older Post](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/close-the-gap-to-keep-workers-safer-and-products-flowing) [Newer Post](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/specialists-in-fall-protection-safety) SHARE THIS PAGE: - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) ### POPULAR TOPICS - [Fall Prevention & Protection (50)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/fall-prevention-protection) - [Fluid Handling (50)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/fluid-handling) - [Safety Equipment Purchasing & Replacement (18)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/safety-equipment-purchasing-replacement) - [Corporate and OSHA Compliance (14)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/corporate-and-osha-compliance) - [safety (9)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/safety) - [Chemical Transfer (7)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/chemical-transfer) - [Marine Fall Prevention & Safety (7)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/marine-fall-prevention-safety) - [Training (7)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/training) - [Truck Safety (7)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/truck-safety) - [Rail Spotting (5)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/rail-spotting) - [Truck Spotting (5)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/truck-spotting) - [Loading Arms (4)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/loading-arms) - [Railroad Saftey (4)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/railroad-saftey) - [Flatbed Tarping (3)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/flatbed-tarping) - [loading rack safety (3)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/loading-rack-safety) - [Crude Oil (2)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/crude-oil) - [ISO Containers (2)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/iso-containers) - [Skid Systems (1)](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/topic/skid-systems) ## RECENT POSTS - [Efficiency and Safety: The Role of Scale Systems in Product Transfer](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/efficiency-and-safety-the-role-of-scale-systems-in-product-transfer) - [Truck and Rail Access Gangways](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/platforms-and-catwalks-the-bones-of-your-operation-0) - [Platforms and Catwalks - The Bones of Your Operation](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/platforms-and-catwalks-the-bones-of-your-operation) - [Truck and Rail Safety Cages – Protection with Room to Move](https://content.carbissolutions.com/blog/truck-and-rail-safety-cages-proper-protection-with-room-to-move-0) ![](https://www.carbissolutions.com/wp-content/themes/carbis/assets/img/logo-footer-new.png) - [Services](https://www.carbissolutions.com/services/) - [Solutions](https://www.carbissolutions.com/solutions/) - [Products](https://www.carbissolutions.com/products/) - [Resources](https://www.carbissolutions.com/resources/) - [About Us](https://www.carbissolutions.com/about-us/) - [Contact Us](https://www.carbissolutions.com/contact/) - [Careers](https://www.paycomonline.net/v4/ats/at-jobopportunities.php?clientkey=FE3AB7EB4121E2287BE5E54B21FD659E) - [Privacy Policy](https://www.carbissolutions.com/privacy-policy/) - [Product Documentation](https://www.carbissolutions.com/product-documentation/) Get in Touch [sales@carbissolutions.com](mailto:sales@carbissolutions) US 1-800-948-7750 Global +1-843-669-6668 Fax 1-843-662-1536 ![](https://www.carbissolutions.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/chat-feature-image.png) Contact a Loading Rack Expert Now. **Safety Consultant Chat Hours:** M-F 8AM-5PM EST [Contact Now](https://www.carbissolutions.com/contact/) © 2018 Carbis Solutions | [Privacy Policy](https://www.carbissolutions.com/privacy-policy/) - - - -